Star Wars: Obi-Wan

Review

by Scott Alan Marriott

Originally designed as the follow-up to 1997's Jedi Knight on the PC, Star Wars: Obi-Wan was officially canceled as a PC title in late 2000 after spending nearly three years in development limbo. The game was not as polished as the two previous Dark Forces titles, and releasing it on the PC would have sullied one of LucasArts' most acclaimed series. This, of course, is small comfort to Xbox owners.

The first notable difference between Jedi Knight and Obi-Wan is the shift from a first-person perspective to a third-person, behind the character viewpoint. This leads to some problems throughout the game, as the camera often reacts slowly to quick movements and has a tendency to jerk around during enemy encounters. It's not the most significant flaw, however. The presentation, level design, and gameplay are all in need of substantial work.

Level design is surprisingly poor, with bland, expansive environments that feel even larger by a conspicuous lack of creatures or objects -- there's little to do besides finding the exit and slashing at the occasional enemy. When you do stumble upon a group of enemies, they are no match for your powers and are quickly disposed of with basic lightsaber attacks. The biggest threat to your life is not combat, but falling off a ledge or a platform.

It's obvious some consideration was given to enemy AI, as a few creatures will run away when hit or attempt to look for cover, but their limited repertoire of moves means they follow the same patterns. The animation doesn't look right, either. Most enemies will take a huge jump backward after each attack, which looks almost comedic.

Despite the game being based on characters from The Phantom Menace, the developers did not have to rely on the movie's storyline for locales. Unfortunately, the places Obi-Wan is sent to in the game aren't very appealing. Flat textures, periodic slowdown, and a dearth of interactive objects make for a boring trek across the galaxy.

The level of control is by far the game's best feature. Players can swing Obi-Wan's lightsaber independently of his movement, using the right analog stick while moving with the left. Force powers, such as throws and weapon pulls, add variety to combat, and are fun to use even if they aren't generally needed. A simple left or right swipe with your lightsaber along with a jump or two will get you through most levels.

The individual lightsaber duels in between levels are more interesting than the main game, but all are easy to win with a few basic attacks. Obi-Wan's block move is so powerful that opponents will be stunned temporarily, allowing you to get in some quick swipes. By repeatedly blocking attacks and then waiting for your chance to strike, you'll be able to defeat most everyone without suffering a scratch.

All things considered, Obi-Wan is a big disappointment. While there is potential here for a great game, it lacks the depth, production values, and fun associated with a quality Star Wars title.